Best Coffee Shops in Brookhaven

top 20 indie spots ranked by nri score. no chains, no filler.

1

Toast Coffee + Kitchen

featured
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.5(1,149)
local cred
95%
nri score84
2

Tend Coffee

featured
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.7(539)
local cred
88%
nri score77
3

CoHo Coffee House

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.7(424)
local cred
72%
nri score69

Southdown Coffee - Port Jefferson

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.7(98)
nri score67

Southdown Coffee - Patchogue

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.6(63)
nri score67

Druthers Coffee

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.5(353)
local cred
72%
nri score67

Brewport Cafe at Sachem Public Library

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
5(5)
nri score67

Brewport Coffee House

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.6(76)
nri score65

Hampton Coffee Company

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.7(50)
nri score65

Bagelati Lake Grove

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.2(49)
nri score62

Bagel Boss Yaphank

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.1(76)
nri score62

Mademoiselle of Patchogue

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.6(101)
nri score61

Duck Donuts

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.6(275)
local cred
72%
nri score61

1905 Featuring Fox's Pizza Den & Southern Ground Coffee Bar

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.2(292)
nri score57

Dog Ear Books & Wild Fox Coffee

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.6(74)
nri score57

WFM Coffee Bar

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.2(14)
nri score54

The Rabbit Hole Brew & Infusion LLC

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.9(50)
nri score52

PJ's Coffee

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4(154)
nri score52

Coffee Booths

verified
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.8(414)
local cred
72%
nri score52

Bellport General

claimed
Brookhaven, USA|cafe
4.4(11)
nri score49