Best Coffee Shops in Oyster Bay

top 20 indie spots ranked by nri score. no chains, no filler.

1

WFM Coffee Bar

featured
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.3(1,482)
local cred
78%
nri score73
2

Southdown Coffee - Oyster Bay

featured
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.6(220)
local cred
72%
nri score71
3

Campground Craft Beer & Coffee

featured
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.9(92)
nri score70

Vice Doughnuts & Coffee

featured
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
5(20)
nri score70

The Grind House

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(191)
nri score69

Thin Cookies

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(120)
nri score68

Mongo's Coffee Roastery & Lounge

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.4(328)
nri score66

Vice Doughnuts & Coffee Farmingdale

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(31)
nri score65

Back In Time, Vintage Home Decor

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(57)
nri score65

Sugar Bae Cafe

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.3(463)
nri score62

Cafe Bella of Massapequa Park

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.9(35)
nri score62

The Crazy Bagel

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.5(141)
nri score59

Flux Coffee

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(523)
local cred
88%
nri score58

Massapequa Perk

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.6(271)
local cred
72%
nri score56

Paris Baguette

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.2(99)
nri score54

Organic Krush Kitchen & Eatery

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.1(136)
nri score52

WFM Coffee Shop

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
0(0)
nri score51

Station Cafe

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.8(16)
nri score48

The Coffee Grind

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.9(75)
nri score48

One Spring Coffee Shop

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.5(125)
nri score47