not another sunday
  • cafesthe global directory
  • roastersevery indie roaster
  • coffeesevery bean, by origin + flavour
  • fresh off the roastthe doors that just opened
  • unusual cafescat cafes, caves, the weird + wonderful
  • in personthe editor's visits
  • best ofcurated city guides
  • wholesalefor cafés buying beans
  • green coffeeimporters, exporters + cooperatives
  • equipmentespresso machines + grinders
  • hand brewdrippers, presses, kettles
  • softwarethe saas stack
  • manufacturersevery brand indexed
  • suppliersgreen sourcing + packaging
  • partner with usfor brands
  • journallong-form editorial
  • blogguides + explainers
  • eventsfestivals + tastings
  • festivalsthe perennial brands
  • championshipswcc, brewers, latte art
  • starting outthe playbook
  • opening a cafereal costs, real timeline
  • starting a roasterymachine selection, sourcing, economics
  • coffee schoolsbarista + roasting training worldwide
  • all tools
  • find my brewmatch a method to your taste
  • coffee quizyour barista personality
  • brew ratiothe calculator
  • caffeine calcby drink + body
  • flavour wheelthe coffee taster's map
  • brand name generatorname your cafe or roastery
  • tasseographyread your grounds
joinfor business
the sunday dispatch

if coffee is your sunday, you'll want what we send.

every sunday morning, one email. the openings, the closures, the championships worth watching. five minutes you'll be glad you spent.

one email a week. unsubscribe whenever.

not another sunday

every great cafe gets found on a sunday.

directory

  • cafes
  • roasters
  • fresh off the roast
  • equipment
  • hand brew
  • manufacturers
  • software
  • roasting machines
  • in person
  • best of
  • wholesale
  • green coffee
  • suppliers
  • packaging

discover

  • events
  • festivals
  • championships
  • journal
  • blog
  • tools

learn

  • starting out
  • opening a cafe
  • starting a roastery
  • coffee schools

for brands

  • claim your listing
  • pricing
  • wholesale featured
  • partner with us
  • nri score
  • about
  • press + brand
  • contact
privacy policyterms of servicecookie policy

caffeinated by gk

do not follow
homecafesusanew york cityButtercup BakeShop

Buttercup BakeShop

973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022
featured
Buttercup BakeShop in New York City, specialty coffee cafe

there's something about the way they pull shots at buttercup bakeshop that makes you understand why people walk past three starbucks to get here. maybe it's the deliberate pace, the way the barista actually watches the extraction instead of multitasking through muscle memory. positioned on 2nd avenue in midtown east, this isn't the kind of place that screams for attention. but 262 google reviewers giving it a solid 4.4 stars tells you everything about consistency. regulars know the rhythm here. they order their usual and settle into conversations that stretch beyond the caffeine transaction. the coffee tastes intentional. not rushed, not burned, not hiding behind flavored syrups. just beans treated with respect and pulled with patience. steam hisses from the machine while the morning crowd builds, each cup handed over with the kind of attention that reminds you why independent coffee matters. some places chase trends. buttercup just makes good…

upgrade to featured for the full editorial profile.

curated by gautam khorana, editor · updated 25 May 2026

nri score72
buzz0
local cred65%

phone

(212) 350-4144

website

buttercupbakeshop.com/

social pulse

0/ 100

no social signal yet. be the first to post about this spot.

google reviews

262

avg rating

4.4

local cred

65%

instagramfacebook

social feed

directionswebsite

nearby in New York City

787 Coffee Co.

787 Coffee Co.

elite
New York City, USA|cafe
4.9(1,582)
new wave
local cred88%
nri score99
Qahwah House

Qahwah House

elite
New York City, USA|cafe
4.8(1,824)
trending
local cred95%
nri score97
Panineria NYC

Panineria NYC

elite
New York City, USA|cafe
4.8(1,284)
trending
local cred90%
nri score96

thinking of starting one?

we wrote the full playbook on opening a cafe, real costs by city, the 90-day pre-launch sequence, equipment essentials, and the mistakes that close cafes in year one.

read the cafe playbook

is this your business?

claim your listing to update your profile, add photos, and boost your nri score.

claim this listing