cold brew or a straight espresso are the obvious calls here, but if you're unsure what to order, let the people who keep coming back guide you: they don't show up to maple ave out of convenience. catalano coffee company sits on a quiet stretch of fair lawn, nj, the kind of town where a good local spot gets tested hard by word of mouth alone, and this one has held up. you don't need a reason to stop in beyond wanting something done with actual care and intention rather than speed. the regulars here are loyal in the specific way people get when a place doesn't slip. fair lawn is a 15-minute drive from manhattan, but catalano feels like its own thing entirely, not a satellite of anywhere. start with the espresso.
curated by gautam khorana, editor · updated
phone
(201) 389-3543
no social signal yet. be the first to post about this spot.
google reviews
96
avg rating
4.8
local cred
30%
thinking of starting one?
we wrote the full playbook on opening a cafe, real costs by city, the 90-day pre-launch sequence, equipment essentials, and the mistakes that close cafes in year one.
read the cafe playbookclaim your listing to update your profile, add photos, and boost your nri score.
claim this listing