
the scent hits you before the door fully opens at otway bakery on fulton street. flour and butter, yes, but also that particular sweetness of dough that's been given proper time to develop. this isn't your grab-and-go situation. the 4.5-star rating from over 200 google reviewers tells part of the story, but standing there watching someone carefully pour your cortado tells the rest. the pastries are what draw people in initially. flaky, substantial things that actually pair with coffee instead of competing against it. but it's the attention to each cup that keeps the morning regulars coming back, clutching their ceramic mugs like small altars to the day ahead. brooklyn has plenty of coffee shops. this one just happens to understand that good coffee and good pastries require the same thing: patience. the steam wand hisses. someone laughs at a corner table. another day begins properly.
curated by gautam khorana, editor · updated
phone
(917) 444-1393
website
otwaynyc.com/no social signal yet. be the first to post about this spot.
google reviews
223
avg rating
4.5
local cred
44%
thinking of starting one?
we wrote the full playbook on opening a cafe, real costs by city, the 90-day pre-launch sequence, equipment essentials, and the mistakes that close cafes in year one.
read the cafe playbookclaim your listing to update your profile, add photos, and boost your nri score.
claim this listing