skip to content

coffee in Oyster Bay

36 cafes · 3 roasters · avg nri 44

see the best coffee shops in Oyster Bay

the best specialty cafes in Oyster Bay are WFM Coffee Bar, Southdown Coffee - Oyster Bay, and Sugar Bae Cafe. they lead 36 independent coffee shops here, ranked by the natural ranking index, a 0-100 merit score blending review quality, local credibility, and web presence. no chains.

featured spot · oyster bay

your roastery, top of oyster bay. this could be you.

top of oyster bay, every search, on rotation. featured listings start at $200/yr.

get featured

every specialty cafe in Oyster Bay, ranked by nri

32 results

WFM Coffee Bar

WFM Coffee Bar

featured
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.3(1,482)
local cred78%
nri score77

Southdown Coffee - Oyster Bay

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.6(220)
local cred72%
nri score67

Sugar Bae Cafe

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.3(463)
nri score63

The Grind House

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(191)
nri score60

The Coffee Grind

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.9(75)
nri score59

Massapequa Perk

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.6(271)
local cred72%
nri score57

One Spring Coffee Shop

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.5(125)
nri score57

Cafe Gondola

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(88)
nri score57

Cafe Bella of Massapequa Park

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.9(35)
nri score57

Thin Cookies

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(120)
nri score55

Center Coffee Shop

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.6(89)
nri score55

Campground Craft Beer & Coffee

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.9(92)
nri score54

SCOOP & COFFEE

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
5(75)
nri score52

Karmic Grind

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(106)
nri score51

Back In Time, Vintage Home Decor

verified
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(57)
nri score51

New York Beanery

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.3(273)
nri score48

Hannah’s Cafe

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.9(53)
nri score48

Station Cafe

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.8(16)
nri score47

Paris Baguette

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.2(99)
nri score45

Panera Bread

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.1(421)
nri score44

YAAAS TEA Syosset

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(23)
nri score40

Cafe La Bella Notte

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.7(15)
nri score39

Sea Cliff Daily Grind

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.2(21)
nri score35

New Jericho Coffee Shop

claimed
Oyster Bay, USA|cafe
4.2(5)
nri score32

faq

what is the best cafe in Oyster Bay?

WFM Coffee Bar is the top-ranked cafe in Oyster Bay, scoring 77/100 on the natural ranking index. it is ranked on review quality, local credibility, and web presence, with chains excluded.

how many specialty coffee shops are in Oyster Bay?

36 independent specialty coffee shops in Oyster Bay, all ranked by the natural ranking index. chains are excluded by default.

where do locals get coffee in Oyster Bay?

WFM Coffee Bar draws the highest share of local regulars in Oyster Bay, with a local-credibility score of 78/100, the proportion of reviewers who live in town rather than visiting as tourists.

browse all 36 cafes in oyster bay